Nyaya

Udayana

Defending the self and arguing for God

c. 10th–11th century CE

01

Life

Udayana was a Nyaya–Vaisheshika philosopher of roughly the tenth and eleventh centuries, associated with Mithila. His surviving works place him in sustained debate with Buddhist accounts of momentariness and non-self, as well as with objections to a creator. A detailed account of his personal life is less secure than the record of these arguments.

02

Contribution

He defends an enduring self partly through questions about memory, recognition and the unity of experience. His arguments for God ask what accounts for an ordered world and other features of cognition and action. These are philosophical inferences within a realist system, not simply appeals to devotional conviction.

03

Key works

Ātmatattvaviveka
A defence of the reality of the self against competing explanations.
Nyāyakusumāñjali
A sequence of arguments concerning the existence of God.
Kiraṇāvalī
A commentary contributing to the Vaisheshika analysis of reality.
04

Legacy

Udayana helped consolidate the interaction of Nyaya and Vaisheshika and prepared problems inherited by later Navya-Nyaya. The strongest way to read him is to identify the explanatory gap each argument claims to fill, then ask whether a rival account can fill it. His importance does not depend on treating the conclusions as beyond criticism.

A question to carry

Does continuity in memory require an enduring subject, or can it be explained by a sequence of connected events?

05

Sources